For wrestling fans, the name AJ Lee conjures up images of rebellious spirit, unmatched charisma, and a reign that redefined what it meant to be a WWE Diva. But then, as quickly as she rose to stardom, she stepped away. Now, whispers of a possible return are swirling. But here’s the thing: it’s not just about if she’ll return, but why it even matters in today’s wrestling landscape.
Why an AJ Lee Comeback Would Be Different This Time

Let’s be honest: wrestling comebacks are a dime a dozen. But an AJ Lee return? That’s different. It’s not just nostalgia. It’s about legacy. When she retired, she cited permanent damage from wrestling as a key factor. So, what would be different now? The wrestling world has changed quite a bit. Promotions like AEW offer a different kind of platform — one that arguably places less emphasis on the grueling travel schedules and potentially risky in-ring style that are prevalent in WWE. Could a different environment be the key to unlocking this potential return? It’s possible! A reduced schedule or a non-wrestling role could be on the cards. Let’s remember, she has remained visible in the wrestling world through her commentary and production work with WOW (Women of Wrestling). The experience she has in professional wrestling adds to this conversation.
And, it’s worth asking, would her return overshadow the current female talent? The answer, in my opinion, is a resounding no. She wouldn’t be replacing anyone; she’d be adding a layer of depth and experience that could elevate the entire division. Her mere presence is a draw.
What the Rumors Are Really Saying About a Potential Return to In-Ring Action
The internet is buzzing, fueled by cryptic social media posts and “insider” reports. Most of these reports should be taken with a grain of salt, but some patterns are starting to emerge. The most persistent rumor revolves around a potential role in AEW, largely due to her husband, CM Punk, working there. Could this be a factor? Absolutely. But it’s not the only one.
Here’s the thing: these rumors often lack concrete sources. So how do we separate fact from fiction? Look for corroboration. Are multiple reputable sources reporting the same information? Is there any official statement from AJ Lee herself, or from either WWE or AEW? Absence of these things does not mean it is not going to happen, it just means it is still a rumor for now.
Ultimately, the truth is that only AJ Lee knows if she truly intends to return to the ring. But as fans, it’s fun to speculate about the possibility of seeing her once again inside those squared circles.
The Emotional Connection | Why Fans Are Desperate for This
Here’s the thing about AJ Lee: she wasn’t just a wrestler; she was an icon for many. She represented the underdog, the unconventional, the fiercely independent woman who didn’t fit the mold. Her character resonated deeply, and her story felt relatable to a generation of fans who felt like outsiders themselves. I initially thought this was straightforward, but then I realized that the connection fans feel to her is complex. It’s not just about wanting to see her wrestle again; it’s about wanting to recapture that feeling of empowerment and inspiration that she embodied.
That moment when she won the Divas Championship? Legendary. The promos she delivered? Unforgettable. For many fans, a potential return to wrestling is about more than just wrestling; it’s about reliving those moments and experiencing that connection again. It’s a nostalgic reminder of when many fans started enjoying wrestling.
The Business Side | Why a Return Makes Sense (Even if it’s Risky)
Let’s put on our business hats for a second. A return of AJ Lee would be a massive draw, regardless of which promotion she joins. She’s a proven commodity, a recognizable name, and a guaranteed ratings boost. For AEW, it would provide a significant boost in their women’s division, injecting a veteran presence and a compelling storyline. For WWE, it would be a chance to reclaim a piece of their history and remind fans of the star power they once possessed. Anchor Text
But there are risks. Her in-ring condition is questionable, and a botched comeback could tarnish her legacy. However, the potential reward far outweighs the risk, making this a gamble worth taking for any promotion. There is potential for the wow factor.
The Role of CM Punk: The Elephant in the Room
Let’s not beat around the bush. The presence of CM Punk in AEW heavily influences the rumors surrounding his wife, AJ Lee. Let me rephrase that for clarity. If he wasn’t in AEW, the rumors of her joining would be severely diminished. AEW have proven to be open to having wrestling couples or groups, so this is not necessarily a bad thing. What fascinates me is how well they can weave this into their product.
But the crucial question is: would AJ Lee only return because of CM Punk? I highly doubt it. While his presence might be a factor, it’s unlikely to be the sole driving force. She is an independent woman with her own ambitions and motivations. We must not diminish the impact she could have on her own merit.
FAQ: Your Burning AJ Lee Return Questions Answered
Frequently Asked Questions
Could she realistically return to WWE?
It’s possible, but less likely given her husband’s history with the company. Never say never in wrestling, but it’s a long shot.
What kind of role would she likely have?
A reduced in-ring schedule is possible, or a non-wrestling role such as a commentator or manager.
Is there any official confirmation of a return?
No, there’s been no official confirmation from AJ Lee or any wrestling promotion.
Where is she now?
After retiring from wrestling, she has remained a New York Times Bestselling Author.
How active is she in wrestling circles?
She has worked behind the scenes on wrestling shows in recent years.
Does April Mendez wrestle anymore?
As of right now, no. Her last match was in 2015. Internal
Ultimately, the question isn’t just if AJ Lee will return, but what her return would signify. It’s a chance to celebrate a groundbreaking career, introduce her to a new generation, and remind us all why we fell in love with wrestling in the first place. And maybe, just maybe, to give her the sendoff she truly deserves.